Understanding the GOP Rating

The Republican National Platform Rating (GOP %) calculates a lawmaker's voting alignment with the policy principles outlined in the 2024 Republican National Platform. Unlike traditional scorecards that grade lawmakers based on organizational or political beliefs such as "conservatism" or "freedom," which can be highly subjective and change over time, the GOP Rating is grounded entirely in the official Republican Party Platform. Adopted at the 2024 Republican National Convention in Milwaukee, the Platform represents a unified policy framework established by Republican leaders and delegates from across the country. Rather than allowing an individual organization to determine what constitutes a Republican position, ILA measures lawmakers against the policy commitments formally adopted by the party itself.

Each piece of legislation is evaluated for its alignment with the Platform's major policy pillars and underlying principles. Every rated vote is tied to a specific policy provision and accompanied by a citation to the relevant section of the Platform, allowing the public to understand exactly how each position is determined. When legislation addresses more granular policy questions not explicitly covered by the Platform, ILA evaluates its consistency with the broader objectives and principles established within the relevant pillar. This creates a transparent and consistent methodology for measuring how closely a lawmaker's voting record reflects the Republican Party's stated policy agenda.

Unlike traditional scorecards that cherry-pick a small selection of votes, the GOP Rating utilizes ILA's extensive legislative dataset, representing the most comprehensive analysis of congressional voting activity ever undertaken. Rather than selecting votes to emphasize particular issues or outcomes, ILA evaluates every substantive policy vote across the full range of legislative activity. At the federal level, this includes final passage votes, amendments, and procedural motions, with exclusions generally limited to non-policy matters such as naming post offices. This comprehensive approach provides a far more complete picture of a lawmaker's alignment with the Republican Platform than conventional scorecards built around a limited selection of votes.

Legislation containing conflicting provisions that obscure a lawmaker's actual policy position is either excluded or evaluated through a subdivided vote-recording method. ILA's comprehensive policy classification system further organizes legislative activity into major policy categories aligned with the Platform's pillars, providing lawmakers with individual ratings across different areas of public policy. By building the methodology around defined policy positions rather than subjective ideological labels, ILA can apply the same framework to lawmakers at the federal and state levels, and even internationally. This allows for direct comparisons across legislative bodies and a broader understanding of how elected officials align with the policy principles adopted by the Republican Party.

Unlike traditional scorecards built around subjective definitions of "conservatism" or "freedom," the GOP Rating measures lawmakers against the Republican Party's own adopted Platform. By evaluating every substantive policy vote against a transparent and consistent framework, ILA establishes a new standard for comparing lawmakers, legislative bodies, and the direction of public policy across the United States and beyond.

The Electorate-Based Grade

The GOP % says how closely a lawmaker's votes align with the 2024 Republican National Platform. The Electorate-Based Grade asks a second question: how does that score compare with what a typical member of the same party scores from a seat whose voters lean the way theirs do?

A Republican from a seat that votes heavily Republican is expected to score higher than one from a seat either party could win, and a Democrat from a competitive seat is expected to score higher than one from a safely Democratic seat. The grade measures each lawmaker against the expectation for their own seat, so a lawmaker who votes with the Platform where the voters lean the other way is credited for it, and more is asked of one whose voters would support it. The Limited Government Index grades the same way, from the LimitedGov %.

How a grade is worked out

  1. The Seat’s Lean. For a member of the House, the Cook Partisan Voting Index (PVI), published by Cook Political Report. It compares how a congressional district votes for president with how the nation votes: R+11 means the district voted about 11 points more Republican than the nation in recent presidential elections, D+5 about 5 points more Democratic, and EVEN about as the nation did. A state that elects a single member of the House is one district.
  2. Electorate Estimate. The score expected of a typical member of the lawmaker's party from a seat with that lean, read from the party's scale (below). Republicans and Democrats each have their own. An Independent is measured as the party they caucus with.
  3. Electorate Alignment. The lawmaker's score, to the whole percent, less the estimate, in points: +6 is six points above what a typical member of their party scores from a seat like theirs, and −4 four points below.
  4. Electorate-Based Grade. The alignment on the party's grade scale (below), from A+ to F: the further above the estimate, the higher the grade. The grade measures the whole score, so the boards set it aside while a category is picked.

Where there is no Cook PVI: margin of victory

The scorecard reads a Cook PVI for House seats. Where a seat has none, its lean is read from a margin of victory instead, on a margin scale for each party, and the estimate, alignment and grade follow from it as above.

Sources: Cook Political Report, for the PVI; the last presidential election's results, for senators; the scorecard's own scales, for the estimates and grades. Where ILA has set a lawmaker's grade for a year by hand, because the worked-out one is known to be wrong for a specific reason, that grade is shown.

2026 Post-Election Simulator: Methodology

Measuring the Ideological Shift in the 2027 Congress

The Institute for Legislative Analysis (ILA) developed the 2026 Post-Election Simulator to measure how the midterm elections will reshape the ideological composition of Congress and the congressional delegations of all 50 states.

Unlike traditional election analysis that focuses on Republican and Democratic seat gains, ILA's simulator projects how the incoming Congress will actually vote, using ILA's Republican National Platform Ratings (GOP%) as the ideological benchmark.

The simulator combines three primary datasets:

  1. ILA's Republican National Platform Ratings (GOP%): Measures lawmakers' voting alignment with the official Republican Platform adopted at the 2024 Republican National Convention.
  2. Cook Political Report's Partisan Voting Index (PVI): Measures the underlying political leanings of congressional districts and states.
  3. 2026 Election Results: Associated Press election results, including party affiliation, winning candidates, and margins of victory.

By combining these datasets, ILA projects the ideological composition of the incoming Congress and calculates how much each state's delegation has shifted.

1. Establishing the Current Congressional Baseline

The simulator begins with ILA's Republican National Platform Ratings (GOP%), which measure how closely each lawmaker's voting record aligns with the official Republican Platform.

ILA evaluates substantive congressional policy votes, including relevant amendments and procedural motions, against the platform's policy principles. Votes are weighted according to their policy significance to calculate each lawmaker's overall GOP%.

The ratings of current lawmakers are then averaged within each state to establish the existing ideological composition of its congressional delegation.

2. Projecting GOP% for Newly Elected Lawmakers

Newly elected members who have not served in Congress do not yet have a voting record. To estimate their expected GOP%, ILA combines the voting patterns of existing lawmakers with the political characteristics of their districts and election outcomes.

Three factors inform each projection:

For example, a Democrat narrowly winning a traditionally Republican district would generally be projected to have a higher GOP% than a Democrat winning overwhelmingly in a heavily Democratic district.

Likewise, a Republican elected from a competitive district may have a different projected GOP% than a Republican elected from an overwhelmingly Republican district.

All projected ratings are expressed on ILA's GOP% scale, allowing direct comparisons between established lawmakers and incoming members.

3. Accounting for Incumbents, Retirements, and Party Flips

The simulator distinguishes among three election outcomes:

Returning Incumbents: Reelected lawmakers retain their existing GOP%, reflecting their actual congressional voting records.

Same-Party Replacements: When a lawmaker retires or is replaced by another member of the same party, ILA uses the outgoing member's GOP% as a reference, alongside Cook PVI and election results, to estimate the incoming member's likely ideological alignment.

Party Flips: When a seat changes parties, ILA projects the incoming lawmaker's GOP% using their party affiliation, Cook PVI, and election margin. Narrow victories generally produce more moderate projections than overwhelming wins in strongly partisan districts.

This approach recognizes that not every Republican or Democrat votes identically, and that a change in representation does not always produce an equally significant ideological shift.

4. Measuring Each State's Ideological Shift

Once projected ratings are established for newly elected lawmakers, ILA calculates the anticipated GOP% of each state's 2027 congressional delegation.

The simulator compares:

A positive shift indicates greater expected alignment with the Republican National Platform. A negative shift indicates movement away from the platform.

This allows users to rank all 50 states by the magnitude of their projected ideological changes, even where the partisan balance of a delegation remains unchanged.

5. Election Results and Projection Updates

The simulator uses Associated Press election results as of November 16, 2026.

For officially called races, the simulator uses the declared winner. For races still being counted, the candidate currently ahead is used provisionally and identified as "Leading."

Projections may change as additional votes are counted and final election margins become available.

For states that redrew congressional districts, the historical comparison uses the previous representative of the same numbered district, which may not represent an identical geographic constituency.

Projected GOP% scores are estimates of expected voting behavior, not actual legislative records. Once incoming lawmakers begin casting votes, their actual GOP% ratings can be calculated through ILA's established methodology.

Understanding the Results

GOP%: A lawmaker's voting alignment with the official Republican National Platform.

Projected GOP%: The estimated platform alignment of a newly elected lawmaker.

State Delegation GOP%: The average GOP% of the lawmakers representing a state.

Ideological Shift: The percentage-point change in a state's delegation GOP% between the current Congress and projected 2027 Congress.

Cook PVI: A measure of the partisan lean of a congressional district or state.

Sources: Institute for Legislative Analysis, Cook Political Report, and Associated Press.